Metallica- "the black album"

This "black album" (officially known as "Metallica") was a massive success for Metallica. It was released in 1991, three years after ...And Justice For All.

Like Dave Brubeck, this is an intimidating classic to comment on! There is not much to say that hasn't been said, starting with the classics of Enter Sandman, The Unforgiven and Nothing Else Matters. The massive cheese-cutter guitar sound has already been discussed at length, as has Lars's neanderthal drumming (Nothing Else Matters would have greatly benefited from a set of brushes and some valium!). So the best I can do is remind you of the goodness of the less-remembered songs.


Sad But True is a slower, grunting song which clearly influenced Rage Against the Machine's style.
Holier Than Thou cranks the tempo back up for a ...ahem... vehement discussion about religion...
To me, the verses of Wherever I May Roam get a bit tedious, but all is forgiven when the fantastic chorus hits.
Don't Tread on Me has a really cool swing groove.
Through the Never alternates between frantic pace and slower breakdowns, following the classic 1980s Metallica style.
Of Wolf and Man is a mid-paced headbanger.
The God That Failed is a bit like The Unforgiven but a bit disjointed in my opinion.
My Friend of Misery also is perfect for headbanging in the verses, with a chorus influencing Rage Against the Machine's style.
The Struggle Within is a frantic 1980s Metallica style song.

Of course this album demanded to be listened to louder than usual. So my neighbours can confirm that the bass guitar and kick drum have huuuuge power, the guitars are grunty yet well defined, the snare is very sharp and the floor tom hits could create earthquakes! At quieter levels, the hi-hat sounds a bit smeared, but crank it up and it falls into place nicely.

Finally, the lyrics are top notch throughout the album.

Favourite songs

Enter Sandman, Holier than Thou, The Unforgiven, Wherever I May Roam, Don't Tread on Me, Through the Never, Nothing Else Matters, Of Wolf and Man, My Friend of Misery

Would I buy it again?

Yes. I don't normally believe in "must have" albums, but this is one that needs to be enjoyed every so often. At maximum volume.