There's no doubt that this album takes a much more pop-focussed approach than previous Muse albums. And it does a very good job of it, because the songs are brimming with great hooks. Therefore, there are two ways I can approach this album: either enjoy the catchy pop fun without over-thinking about it, or get on my pretentious high-horse and bemoan the dumbing down of Muse. Of course... I choose the latter!
It's not just that the songs are simplistic; after all, much of Showbiz's appeal is its raw simplicity. However, songs like Uprising and Undisclosed Desires sees these musical ideas are drowning in all kinds of unnecessary instruments, overdubs and effects. Also, I find the lyrics are completely emotionally detached. Muse's nonsensical metaphysical lyrics have always been a highlight for me... but... "love is our resistance", what on earth does that even mean??
Despite all these misgivings, I still thoroughly enjoy Uprising, Resistance and Undisclosed Desires. Argh, the pop hooks are simply irresistible!
The recording quality seems to be aimed at achieving a big sound at any cost. Some of the sweetness and clarity is lost as a result, but the huge scale is definitely achieved.
United States Of Eurasia is some kind of terrible attempt at a Queen tribute. Guiding Light is just overblown, self-indulgent stadium rock. And MK Ultra somehow feels like a poor imitation of early Muse.
On a brighter note, Unnatural Selection is a brilliant rock-opera. It jumps all over the place, but it does it so seamlessly that it's actually adds to the appeal. It is everything I'd hoped for in Muse's fifth album and by far the highlight.
As for Exogenesis, I suspect it would make a wonderful soundtrack to a short film. However, as a standalone artwork, I think it is pointlessly rambling prog-rock which is hiding behind the camouflage of some tacked-on strings. Not to mention the piano melody of Part 3 is pretty much a rip-off of Moonlight Sonata.
No comments:
Post a Comment