Wednesday, May 13, 2015

Various- All Our Loving

This compilation from 1999 features the same song twelve times! It's a variety of "indie" bands covering The Beatles' All My Loving.

To its credit, the album covers a huge variety of styles. The downside is that a lot of them are not to my taste! So I'll just focus on the songs that perked my interest.

Muzzy Pep's lounge-jazz style works quite well. And the pop-rock chorus is also pretty solid, if a little generic. The problem is when the two shoehorned together into a song, they completely undermine each other.

If Ramones were still around and somehow got a slot on this compilation album, Nitocris' version is pretty much what it would sound like. In other words, it is pop-punk perfection.

The Porkers brand of frenetic ska-rock is something I'm quite fond of. So the Richard Cheese-esque (ie tongue-in-cheek lounge-jazz) verses are a nice surprise and work very well. Unfortunately, the other sections of the song jump all over the place, so the songs ends up as a bit of a dogs breakfast.

I wish I could say this album has also opened up my eyes to new bands. But unfortunately, there wasn't anything new here that really appealed to me.

Favourite songs

Nitocris, The Porkers

Worthwhile?

Normally, the answer would be "no". But the Nitocris version is a crucial part of my favourite mix-tape, so I have a moral obligation to purchase this album...

No comments:

Post a Comment